Categories | Attributes | Indicator | Questions | Guidance | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Legal protection, access to justice and remedy | |||||
Access to justice and remedy | Access to and equality before courts and tribunals |
Indigenous peoples and communities have recognized juridical personality with capacity to hold rights, defend/litigate rights and seek remedies for violations
(I99) Structural indicator
| Are indigenous peoples recognised as legal entities (juridical personalities) in national legislation, with capacity to defend/litigate rights and seek remedies for violations? Q63(LNS)
Response options 1: Yes
2: No | According to Article 40 of UNDRIP, indigenous peoples have the right to access procedures aiming to resolve conflicts with states and other parties, and the right to seek remedies for violations of their individual and collective rights. In order to ensure effective access of indigenous peoples to these mechanisms, it is important that they have the possibility to be recognised collectively as legal entities or juridical personalities. | |
Proportion of indigenous prison inmates as compared to their total proportion of the population
(I28) Outcome indicator
| Of the total number of prison inmates, what percentage constitutes indigenous inmates? Q68(LNS)
Response options 1: Percentage
2: No data available | This question monitors indigenous peoples’ access to and equality before courts and tribunals. | |||
Indigenous peoples and communities have recognized juridical personality with capacity to hold rights, defend/litigate rights and seek remedies for violations
(I99) Structural indicator
| Is your people/community recognised as a legal entity (juridical personality) that can hold rights, defend and litigate rights and seek remedies for violations? Q72(LCS)
Response options 1: Yes
2: No | Is your people/community recognised as having its own distinct identity and legal personality, with all associated legal duties and rights? Does your community have the right to act as a collective before the legal authorities (hold contracts, approach the courts, etc.)? If yes – you are indeed recognized as a legal entity, and you can answer ‘yes’ to this question. If not, please click ‘no’. | |||
Access to remedy for infringement of rights |
Sanctioning of violators of indigenous peoples’ rights to lands and territories
(I5) Outcome indicator
WCIP para. 24
| If your people/community, since 2008, has experienced violations of their rights to lands, territories or resources, have the perpetrators been sanctioned by the national judicial system? Q50(LCS)
Response options 1: Yes
2: No | If your people/community has experienced violations of your rights to lands, territories and resources since 2008, indicate whether the people committing these abuses have been penalized by a court. Please provide additional information in the box below on any such cases. | ||
Incidents of court rulings that provides remedy for infringements of indigenous peoples’ collective rights
(I69) Outcome indicator
| Have there, since 2008, been incidents of court rulings that provide remedy for infringements of indigenous peoples’ collective rights? Q66(LNS)
Response options 1: Yes
2: No | This questions monitors indigenous peoples’ access to remedy for infringement of their collective rights. | |||
Possibility to take legal action to litigate rights and seek remedies for violations
(I152) Outcome indicator
| Has your people/community been able to take legal action to litigate rights and seek remedies for violations? Q73(LCS)
Response options 1: Not at all
2: To a limited extent 3: To some extent 4: To a considerable extent 5: Fully 6: We have not experienced violations that would require legal action and remedies | Please indicate to what extent your people/community is actually able to take legal action and seek remedies, when their rights are violated. You are given five response actions: | |||
If your community/people does not have full opportunity to take legal action, which are the restrictions that you encounter (tick as many boxes as relevant): Q74(LCS)
Response options 1: Nonrecognition of your rights in the national legal framework
2: Low awareness in your community/people about rights and legal opportunities 3: Lack of necessary financial resources 4: Limited access to legal aid 5: Language barriers 6: Distance to judicial institutions 7: Others | If your people / community face barriers to take legal action and seek remedy, please identify the factors that limit youraccess to justice here. Please note that you can tick as many boxes as relevant, and also identify other factors that are relevant in your context. If you tick the “others” option, then please provide additional information. The response options listed are the following: | ||||
Access to translation in legal proceedings |
The right to access to translation into indigenous languages in legal proceedings is recognized in the national legislation
(I76) Structural indicator
| Is the right to access to translation into indigenous languages in legal proceedings recognized in national legislation? Q64(LNS)
Response options 1: Yes
2: No | Indigenous peoples are often not familiar with national laws or the national legal system and do not have the educational background or the economic means to ensure their access to justice. Often, they do not speak or read the official language used in legal proceedings, and they may find courts, hearings or tribunals confusing. To address this situation, Article 13(2) of UNDRIP stipulates that "States shall take effective measures to ensure that […] indigenous peoples can understand and be understood in political, legal and administrative proceedings, where necessary through the provision of interpretation or by other appropriate means." | ||
Consideration of customary law in legal proceedings |
Incidents of court rulings, which take into consideration customary law
(I71) Outcome indicator
| Have there, since 2008, been incidents of court rulings that take into consideration customary law? Q65(LNS)
Response options 1: Yes
2: No | Article 40 of UNDRIP holds that decisions on conflict and dispute resolution and remedies "shall give due consideration to the customs, traditions, rules and legal systems of the indigenous peoples concerned". This question is therefore related to the broader question of recognition of customary law (addressed question 30). | ||
Public hearing by competent and independent courts |
Training courses for judges and legal workers on indigenous peoples’ rights
(I7) Process indicator
| Does the State provide training courses on indigenous peoples’ rights for the following groups? Q67(LNS)
Response categories Judges
Law enforcement agencies Other legal workers Response options 1: Yes
2: No | This question monitors whether appropriate procedures are in place to secure that courts are competent to hear indigenous peoples’ cases. | ||